2 Cool Fishing Forum banner

Shimano Chronarch Ci4 spool corrosion

59K views 95 replies 34 participants last post by  Dan Thorburn  
#1 ·
I purchased my new Ci4 about 3 months ago. I have fished it about 20 times or so. I wipe it down with damp cloth of warm water after each trip. After it air dries I put it back in a neoprene reel cover. There is not a scratch on it.

So I'm getting ready for a sat trip to Baffin and I'm doing the pre-trip inspection. I pop out the spool and I notice some whitish green specks on the edge of the spool. The side that is next to the main gear had pitting and corrosion build up all along the edge rim of the spool. My real has never been dunked, abused, or neglected in any way. I took it back to Roy's and they called Shimano. Shimano made it right after Roy's described what the spool looked like and they are sending me another spool.

Any one else experience this same issue?
 
#2 ·
I have had a customer call me with that very issue. I dont have any other information besides what you have just described. It sounded like he took the exact same care in terms of maintenance. I directed him to Shimano as well...Dip
 
#4 ·
I have a brand new one that will spend the rest of the winter with me in fla. where it will be my top water rig. What I would like is a plan to keep this from happening.
Pull the spool and wipe down with corrosion x every few days?
 
#5 ·
Unfortunately it takes more than water to get the salt off, which will cause pitting in everything after long periods. I was told by the reel guys at FTU to use a 25% windex to water solution and spray that on. It gets the salt off and its cheaper than some of the other reel cleaning sprays that are out there.
 
#6 ·
I have the same problem on the same side of the spool, pitting/corrosion of the edge, happened within a month and I take very good care of my gear. I break my reels down once a week for a full cleaning. I guess I need to contact Shimano, was really disappointed with this.
 
#8 ·
Chronarch Ci4 Spool corrosion

I spoke to another friend that has the same reel. He said he would check his Chronarch Ci4 and call me back. He called me back and was pretty upset because his looked the same way. He's only had his for about 2 months.

Although I'm sure Shimano will rectify any similar claims I'm at odds of what to do. Ive never had this issue with my Core 50mg7 and I never wiped down the spool.. I upgraded from my core to my Ci4 because the materials were supposed to be better for the saltwater environment. Unless I get some updated information from Shimano as to why my Ci4 did this and none of my other Shimano reels I've owed for over 30 years have not i might be putting this puppy on ebay and going back to my core 50mg7's.

I was hoping Bantam might have some updated info on the subject.
 
#9 ·
Chronarch Ci4 spool corrosion

Dan

My apologies. I must have been posting at the same time you posted your updated information on my original post. Thank You for looking into the matter. Please keep us updated.

MD
 
#12 ·
CI4

These are pictures of my CI4 spool. I am the customer that Dispay refers to. The reel is at Shimano but they are having a hard time locating my package (signed for on 12-7). And yes I do wash my reels down with salt away and distilled water after every use. The reel was purchased in October of 2013.
 

Attachments

#24 ·
These are pictures of my CI4 spool. I am the customer that Dispay refers to. The reel is at Shimano but they are having a hard time locating my package (signed for on 12-7). And yes I do wash my reels down with salt away and distilled water after every use. The reel was purchased in October of 2013.
Hope you get another.

This close up looks to me like the reel is hosed down and not dried instead of misting and wiping down. Water alone will not remove the salt and if it sets it is even worse. Anyone can remove their spool to wipe down as it is no different then opening the side to adjust brakes except you pull the spool out as well while open.
 
#16 ·
Do you have microscope eyes to tell what material it is in the picture? We are using A7075 which is then anodized. It looks like saltwater sat on the spot where it corroded. Our QC team and the factory people are inspecting the samples we received. I heard about it right before I went on vacation and now I am on the road visiting dealers. I will try to get an update. The good news is that the reels are still under warranty.
 
#17 ·
Just got off the phone with Doug B at Shimano. He told me that my reel
had the first "new version" spool installed and would be shipped to me tomorrow. I do not know what is new about it but he asked me to give him
a report in three weeks.
 
#20 ·
Interesting. Like others do, I mist and wipe off reels but never take out the spool to wipe it down unless it gets splashed while wade fishing. I guess I will start that from now on too.
My old chronarchs I mist and dry off after each trip and then break down once a week for a full cleaning.

Ive found with this new chronarch it has to be broken down after every trip because of the build up the develops along the edges of the frame along the spool and elsewhere. I love the way it works when it's clean but it is very high maintenance compared to my old 100s
 
#21 ·
You guys were freaking me out! I bought my Ci4 8-17-13 and have used it a ton in the salt. I do wash my equipment down very well after every trip. I'm usually on the road so they get to get in the shower with me. I went to inspect mine closer just now with my +2.50 glasses I use to get up close and personal. I didn't see anything at all wrong??? It will be interesting to see what Shimano finds out.
 
#30 ·
George the close up pictures that I posted of the corrosion on my spool may look like I do not take care of my equipment. I will assure you that my reels are sprayed with salt away and distilled water, rinsed and wiped dry. The suspected salt on the spool is actually clear finger nail polish that I put over the corrosion.
 
#31 ·
Sweet!! At least with the finger nail polish should give you more time sealing it off as long as all the corrosion is dug out. Not trying to say you don't take care of your stuff just stating what I saw initially in the close up which is merely an opinion as I can not see it under a microscope to verify. Even if I did I wouldn't know what the hell I was looking at trying to verify metals as I don't do that for a living nor have I tried it. Keep us updated what Shimano does about this.
 
#34 ·
Dan - I assume Shimano determined there was an issue with the spool and has corrected same. Is there some way consumers can determine if the reel has a questionable spool? I was planning on purchasing one soon, but have put it on the back burner until this all gets worked out.
 
#36 ·
I'm glad im not the only one who is experiencing this. I kept quiet because i figured it was just my spool that was getting it. I have the same exact spots showing up on mine and i take great care of all my reels..including mg's and i've never had this problem.

i bet there are alot more people who are experiencing this and will keep quiet/not see this thread.