You have to go buy the video, "Don't shoot young big bucks" # 1 & # 2 I think you would really like to see how this guy judges and scores deer. If you haven't seen it, it makes for a great deer camp watch. Your buck looks 4 to me. Great deer!
#1 is no 3.5 atleast 4.5 prob a 5.5 notice the roman nose loose skin fold under the jaw line and the sway back. If high fenced I would give him another year maybe 2 but there is no shame in taking him on a low fenced ranch this year. 2 and 3 are shooters for sure both apear to be post mature bucks 6.5 to 7.5.