Shawn is right, Matt. 30 seconds too long and it is like eating a tire. My preference is to hit the seasoning very lightly so you don't cover up the taste of the fish. I just use a little salt, onion powder, and Chef Paul Prudhomme's Seafood Majic or Blackened Redfish Seasoning Mix. A couple of good side dishes for that are macaroni and cheese and fresh green beans with a few cut up red-skin taters, steamed until the taters are tender and the beans still have just a little bit of "snap" left in 'em.
Excellent fried. Trim off the red meat, cut fillets into 1/2 inch medallions, a little chachere's on the meat, roll in cornmeal, then the grease. If you grill it, do it on tin foil or in a fish basket, it tends to flake apart on the grill.
IMHO, it is not only unnecessary to turn fish while grillin', it is the wrong thing to do. I leave the skin attached and put the fish on the grill skin side down. Comes out juicy and tender and flaky every time no matter how thick the steak/fillet is.
Sounds great Shawn. I just put this into my recipes folder and I'll be givin' it a test real soon. Just from lookin' at the 'grediments and trying to imagine all those flavors blended, I expect it to be very good. Once I try it I'll catch up with ya and give ya a report on how it went.
There was a lady who had a fish smoking business and her specialty was Amberjack. People at the local Tiki Bars would eat them in small square chunks on toothpicks. It was the thang at the bars up and down the Keys instead of pretzels or goldfish crackers.
If you caught an AJ, you'd filet out the back on each side and take it to her. She in turn would trade with you already smoked fish in the amount equal to half the weight of your raw fish. YUM!! CF?
I agree with all the above advice but will add it is great fried in a beer batter! Here is my recipe
Cut AJ into 1 to 1 1/2 inch medallions
Bring peanut oil to 375 degrees. Use a thermometer since frying temp is very important. I also use at least 1/2 gallon of oil on a powerful outdoor burner to keep the temp up after adding the fish. Use more oil for more fish.
1 cup flour
3 T corn starch
1 t salt
1 cup beer (wheat, light etc. don't recommend dark beers)
1 T vegetable oil
Mix dry ingredients, then blend in beer and the vegetable oil. Drink remaining 4 ounces of beer.
you may add some paprika, nutmeg, cayenne pepper if you would like.
Pre heat oven to 500 degrees, yes, 500, for the weak at heart, 475 will be OK.
If you have a convection oven, that is best.
Use nice filets, not more 3/4" to 7/8" thick. Do not season.
Heat skillet very hot, as if to blacken (if you have a no-stick surface, great, try to use no oil, ........it will burn and taint the fish)
Drop the filets into skillet, cook 1 minute each side. Do not blacken.
Remove filets to a small cake cooling rack (a wire rack) and place this rack onto a cookie sheet. Place into screaming hot oven for 3-4 minutes, yes, 3-4 min., and serve immediately. It should be golden brown, not dark.
This method renders the surface of the fish crunchy, and the middle of the meat juicy, shiney, and translucent.........just right.
May have to experiment with this method, it is easy to screw-up. I had several pieces I did in succession to establish my correct cooking times. The bothched ones went well with catsup and a cold Shiner.
May use the sauce of your choice, but AJ doesnt need flavor inhancement.
Works well with redfish, snapper, ling, etc., but not trout, as it will fall apart.